Judge Me Reviews

Judge Me Reviews

Based on 775 reviews
88%
(684)
6%
(43)
4%
(28)
1%
(10)
1%
(10)
Height: 6'2"
Weight: 165
Size: L
Exceptional Quality, Fit and Finish

I was a bit reluctant to make this purchase because I couldn't decide whether the Medium or Large would be the best fit. For items like this, I would normally buy a Medium. For reference, I'm 6'2" and 165 lbs. After going back and forth - and reading that this garment is intended as an overshirt - I decided on the Large size. Lucky for me, the fit is perfect. It's not too big. It drapes beautifully, and the design, with its simplicity and clean lines, is exactly what I was looking for. I'm hard to please when it comes to clothing. Purchasing online is even more daunting. Ordering internationally without a return policy felt like a real bet. However, I made the bet, and I'm very happy that I did. I've had it for less than a week and have received multiple compliments from multiple strangers, which is unusual - more of a testament to its beautiful simplicity.

Quality Oxford shirt

Quality Oxford shirt fits well feels well in good price

Height: 6 feet
Weight: 12 stone
Size: 15 collar
One of the best OCBDs I've worn

A truly excellent shirt. Flattering in fit without being overtailored, sturdy yet breathable cloth and immaculate quality of detail and finish. A premier garment that thoroughly justifies a premium price; I shall be sure to buy another!

Height: Six feet
Weight: 12 stone
Size: M
One of the best OCBDs I've worn

A truly excellent shirt. Flattering in fit without being overtailored, sturdy yet breathable cloth and immaculate quality of detail and finish. A premier garment that thoroughly justifies a premium price; I shall be sure to buy another!

Height: 6'1
Weight: 200 lbs
Size: 17
Another winner!!!

This shirt is another work of art. Looks fantastic and is just a super cool shirt. As I mentioned in another review, I ordered a full size up.

Height: Jascha Preuss
Weight: 175 lbs
Size: M - 16
Great OCBD - but be aware of fading navy color

I own about a dozen Kamakura OCBD, and at least 5 in the Vintage Ivy series. An extra button at the bottom of the front placket would be great for taller people, but that's just a nice to have. The shirts get better with washing, except the NAVY one. The color fades (to be expected) even with cold washing and air drying. I find it makes the shirt a little less attractive than the others. It's a common problem with dark navy cotton garments after repeated washing. I will buy more Vintage Ivy shirts for sure, just not this color.

Great shirt. Perfect

great shirt

absolutely top quality shirts love it

Height: 5’09”
Weight: 200 lbs
Size: 46”
My favorite cardigan

This sweater does everything I wanted it to do and more. Casual or dressy. Cozy but never hot. An heirloom quality piece to last my lifetime and for one of my kids to inherit and enjoy. Thank you Kamakura Shirt for your good taste, and intentionality in quality execution.

Height: 185cm
Weight: 95kg
Size: 46 us

Amazing shirt. The way it pairs with a pair of cowboy cut Wranglers and a type 3 jean jacket…perfect.

(It’s also great with just about anything else.)

J
M211S2319QBVIV VINTAGE IVY OXFORD【Trunk show limited】
Jayesh

Excellent

J
M251S0260BVIV VINTAGE IVY Chambray【Trunk show limited】
Jayesh

Construction is flawless, great color.

Height: 1.81m
Weight: 78kg
Great shirt but sizing comes up small

Fabulous quality and manufacture but comes up much smaller than measurement indicate around the chest. Leno fabric exactly what i wanted for a lightweight breathable summer shirt

Height: 6ft
Weight: 170
Size: Medium
The best all around clothing ever made.

I have yet to purchase one of this companies clothes and be anything less than blown away. I do chores with my two year old daughter and train in the dojo with equal ease in these samues.

Height: 6ft
Weight: 172
Size: Medium
Why wear anything else?

This is top tier clothing for a third less the price. I can’t say enough about the feel of this denim. This is clothes for all aspects of life and I can’t recommend enough that you try this companies samue’s.

Height: 5'10"
Weight: 130 lbs
Size: 15
Yellow Stripe Seersucker BD

A quintessential summer Ivy staple. Beautiful lightweight material and a great fit (product sizing guide is very accurate). The (51) colour is best described as a muted yellow ochre rather than a bright sunshine yellow. Disappointingly, the ever-popular Blue (21) was out of stock in size 15. My only regret is that a short-sleeve version isn't currently available.

Height: 5'8"
Weight: 213 lbs
Size: XL
Fantastic Shirt

probably the best OTR Oxford i've ever purchased - heard a lot of great things from this brand through various blogs/forums. Fabric is substantial, but soft and broken in immediately out of the package. The length and cut is extremely wearable and perfect for casual untucked wear without worrying about excess length, cut with just enough room even for a regular lifter like me, loved it so much i bought a blue then immediately a white - excited to have this be a wardrobe staple for years to come. shipping was very fast, given it was coming from japan to the east coast usa - love this shirt and brand !

A perfect shirt

A stunning shirt that looks even better in person. An important thing to keep in mind is that I ordered a full size up since Japanese sizes tend to run smaller. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!!!

Size: 15.5
Fantastic shirt with unusual fit

Let me state that this is a fantastic shirt. The cloth and shape are both wonderful. But the sizing is a little strange: I went with size 15.5 because of the listed neck and sleeve measurements, however the sleeves are a little long while the neck is a little small.

I would usually go for a size 16 in shirts because that's the right neck size for me, but the 15.5 seems to have a 16in/40.5cm neck measurement. The 15.5 also has the correct neck to sleeve measurement for me, which is about 87cm. But after trying on the shirt, the neck feels like 15.5in! The sleeves are also possibly a little longer than listed.

To go for a larger neck size I'd also have to get longer sleeves, but I need the sleeves to be shorter in which case I'd have to get a smaller neck size. In all, it's a lovely shirt but I'm confused at what body shape this is cut for, given the large chest, long sleeves, but narrow neck.

Height: 5'10"
Weight: 200
Size: 46R
Beautiful, Amazing Shirt: for someone very thin!

Shoulders, collar, and cuffs fit perfectly. The shirt is gorgeous, of the quality I haven't seen from top US brands since the 1990s. The torso, though, is cut to fit a 40" chest comfortably, 42" snugly, and - not so much my 46" frame.

perfectly !

all perfect- shirt, material, transport, size, cut . Bravo!

Height: 5’9”
Weight: 187
Size: 17
Outstanding Quality

So hard to find this kind of quality these days. So impressed and happy. Will be buying more.

Height: 1.67m
Weight: 88kg
Size: 17.5 neck size
Exceptional

Always consistently superior.

Height: 6’2”
Weight: 180lbs
Wearing it now

Most comfortable Oxford I’ve ever worn.