Judge Me Reviews

Judge Me Reviews

Based on 583 reviews
88%
(515)
6%
(34)
3%
(16)
2%
(9)
2%
(9)

Very good quality silk, well made, excellent value for money.

Height: 6
Weight: 185
Size: Large, 16 1/2 - 35.
Ill fitting shirt. Terrible return policy.

My wife purchased this shirt (in red) as a Christmas gift for me. I own a Kamakura OCBD from the Vintage Ivy Collection. So I was fairly confident on the size. In most shirting, I am a 16 1/2, 35. Based on the measurements provided on the brushed cotton twill, my wife ordered me a large. When the shirt arrived, the shirt was not only too small, the fit was extremely awkward: the sleeves were too short; the collar was too tight; and the hem hung awkwardly around my navel (much too short). While it would not generally have been a huge issue to exchange the shirt for a larger size, Kamakura's charges for return shipping are outrageous. They do not offer exchanges, which means I would have had to return the shirt and then order another one. To return the shirt, Kamakura deducted 40 dollars from my refund, and would have charged me 20 more dollars to ship me a new one. That means that, to return the shirt and order a shirt that fit, I would have to spend 80 dollars in shipping. If the replacement shirt didn't end up fitting, I would have had to return it and be charged another 40 dollars in shipping. I have never encountered a more outrageous return policy. If you purchase a shirt, and want to exchange it, Kamakura should cover the shipping. I did not end up ordering a replacement shirt as I did not want to spend 80 dollars in shipping to get a shirt that fit! Because the measurements provided by Kamakura were not accurate, I ordered a shirt that was too small and ended up paying 60 dollars total in shipping to return a shirt and not get a replacement. For that reason, I will not be ordering any further Kamakura products in the future and would not recommend anyone else doing so unless you are cool with paying outrageous shipping to return your shirt.

Dear Kelly C,

We sincerely apologize for the frustration you experienced with your recent order and return process. We understand how disappointing it must have been to receive a shirt that didn’t fit as expected, and we regret any inconvenience caused.

After reviewing the records, we’d like to clarify the breakdown of the USD 40 deduction. USD 25 covered the initial shipping cost to send the shirt to you, while USD 15 was for the return shipping label. As an international retailer, our shipping and tax costs often exceed the fees we charge customers, but we strive to keep them as reasonable as possible.

Regarding sizing, we do our best to provide accurate measurements in our size chart. If the actual shirt dimensions had varied by more than 2%(within 2% is the generally accepted tolerance in apparel manufacturing) from the listed measurements, we would have gladly covered the return shipping as a defective item. In such cases, we encourage customers to reach out so we can resolve the issue promptly.

We truly appreciate your feedback and regret that this experience did not meet your expectations. If there’s anything further we can do to assist you, please don’t hesitate to let us know.

Best regards!

Height: 194cm
Weight: 103kg
Size: 17,5
Super, smashing, great

I bought two Vintage Ivy tab collar shirts after seeing Kamakura recommended on Instagram and reading about tab collars in Graham Marsh’s book. The tab collars make such a difference. I was on a work trip to Milan (during fashion week as well) and didn’t feel too out of place without having to go to any extra effort

Beautiful fabric, great construction & fit. Fits as listed in the size chart.

Apparently, I am NOT a 161/2-34 in this Tokyo Slim Fit. The sleeves are at least 1” too short. Looks ok when your arms are at your side, but the moment you extend your arm to shake someone’s hand, the sleeve rides up. I emailed Kamakura Shirts asking for a solution, stating that I travel to Japan annually and always wanted to try this shirt brand as I would likely buy more. Also, it would appear, that a 161/2-35 is not offered. So FAR, no one has replied to my email.

Height: 6’3”
Weight: 209kg
Size: 17.5”
lovely fit and finish

perfect oxford shirt for work and leisure. Needs another button

Height: 6'5"
Weight: 245
Size: 48 long
No where near a traditional Ivy cut by US standards

I was so excited to receive my first shirt from Kamakura today. I had read about Kamakura on Ivy Style. I bought the biggest shirt available a "17 1/2". The size chart said 26 1/2" sleeve. It's a great looking tatersall fabric with great details (box pleat, locker tab). I am 6'5" and weigh 250 lbs (38 inch waist). Imagine my horror when I tried it on and discovered by "trad" US standards, my beautiful shirt is really a "slim cut". Wonderful company but their ready to wear is not "Ivy" cut ...not by a mile. Too much trouble to return to Japan. "Once burned twice shy"...regretably becuase it is a beautiful shirt. Hey! Maybe I wll suddenly lose 30 pounds. I'll stick with J. Press, O'Connells, The Andover Shop and Cordings.

Dear Jeff,
Thank you for your feedback and for giving our shirt a try.
We are sorry to hear that the fit didn’t meet your expectations.
We would love to help you find a better option through our Made-to-Order (MTO) service, where we can tailor a shirt to your preferred measurements. If you're interested, we are happy to guide you through the process to ensure the perfect fit. Please feel free to reach out, we’re always here to help!
Best regards!

Subtle, classy sheen and perfect construction.

Me Milestones and Kamakura

I have wanted a Green Ivy Style shirt and admired Kamakura clothing for a long time so finally getting both in one go is a thrill. Beautiful shirt. I will be collecting more pieces from Kamakura for sure.

Height: 6'0
Weight: 225
Size: 46 L
Love this shirt.

It's a great fit. The shirt has a great feel to it. Not too tight, but not overly blousy. The collar is the best I've worn on an button down oxford. It was so comfortable I wore it two days in a row.

Quality

Kamakura shirts use the best fabrics and construction. Everything is painstakingly put together - nothing beats it in the US for the price.

Height: 183 cm
Size: 15.5
A Disappointing Experience with This Denim Shirt

I had high hopes for this denim shirt, but unfortunately, it turned out to be a letdown. After just two weeks of wear, the material on the elbows has noticeably faded, making the shirt look old and worn out much sooner than I expected.

Given the price and initial appearance of the shirt, I expected it to hold up better over time. I followed all the care instructions precisely, so there’s no excuse for such rapid wear. The fading on the elbows isn’t just subtle—it’s glaringly obvious, which makes the shirt unsuitable for anything other than casual, at-home wear now.

This is disappointing for a product marketed as durable and stylish. If you're looking for a denim shirt that will maintain its quality, I suggest looking elsewhere. This one doesn’t live up to its promises.
On the picture I attached it looks better than in reality.

Dear Michael,
Thank you for sharing your feedback. We're truly sorry to hear about your experience with the denim shirt. We’ll pass your concerns about the fabric and durability to our production team for review. We appreciate your understanding and are here to assist further if needed. Best regards!

Height: 5'8"
Weight: 155lbs
Size: 15.5
It's in the cloth

The shirt captures the classic Ivy shirts that I stole from my father's closet when I was a teenager. I searched high and low for the right look.... the right cut and the correct cloth, for years as a adult. It can be found only in the Kamakura Ivy collection.

Great style, bad durability

I bought multiple pairs of these and introduced them to my sock rotation around a year ago. I really enjoy the styling of these, they are just about perfect. Unfortunately multiple pairs have already torn a big hole around the heel. For the price-point I expected better.

Height: 188
Weight: 83
Size: 86

Very good demin. The color is true to pictures and the sizing is perfect. Very happy with it.

Great looking, superb quality shirts

Classic detailing and fit, the best Ivy shirt on the market.

Perfect shirt

Very high-quality shirt, soft cloth, pearl buttons, dense and even stitches.

Perfect shirt

Very high-quality shirt, soft cloth, pearl buttons, dense and even stitches.

Perfect shirt

Very high-quality shirt, soft cloth, pearl buttons, dense and even stitches.

Nice material

It feels soft and comfortable

Height: 180cm
Weight: 80kg
Size: Large (16)
High quality OCBD

The fabric is great, sturdy and compact and becomes soft after the first wash. High quality stitching throughout and nicely finished button holes. I am 180cm tall with athletic build and purchased size Large (16) which fitted well across the shoulders and chest but had a surplus of material around the waist. The shirt would have been 5-stars had the side seems around the waist been tapered by about 10cm overall.

Height: 5'3
Weight: 134
Size: 38-79
Great fit

As someone who's 5'3 it's hard to find dress shirts with the right proportions but the 38-79 size is very well-fitting for my arms and body - quality is good as always with Kamakura. Recommended!

Love it

This item is very comfortable and lightweight. It will keep you warm.

nice product

very nice product