Judge Me Reviews

Judge Me Reviews

Based on 835 reviews
88%
(735)
6%
(47)
4%
(31)
1%
(10)
1%
(12)
Height: Robson
Weight: 175
Size: 39-83
First and love it!

Perfect fit with the sleeve length adjustment. The light blue color had very good opacity.

Height: 181cm
Weight: 93kg
Size: 16.5
The best

Absolutely love these shirts! The vintage Ivy is my new go to. The fit, the details, they iron up so easily. I have 7 different colours now, can’t see myself ever buying another brand again.

Shrinkage

After first wash in cold water and hanging to dry, the shirt shrunk and is unwearable.

Height: 6 ft.
Weight: 174 on a good day
Size: L
One of the best Vintage Ivy products yet

I love the color of the green buttondown brushed oxford (the photos are an accurate representation) and the soft yet substantial cotton almost feels like a lightweight flannel.

Height: 184cm
Weight: 98
Size: 17,5
More than datisfied

The hole expierence was more than satisfying! Marvellous shirt! No extra cost! Wont be the last shirts i am going to buy!

Height: 5’10”
Weight: 155lbs
Size: 40
Flawless coat

Title says it all - flawless. Material is very nice, the reversible feature is done extremely well, and the fit is excellent. Brings that perfect balance of fashion that catches the eye with the timelessness and practicality of business attire. Looks just like the photos except the quality is even more noticeable in person.

Love the fabric! Well-made shirt.

W
M211S2319QBVIV VINTAGE IVY OXFORD【Trunk show limited】
William

It fits perfectly and is wonderful fabric.

A masterpiece of Ivy League tailoring

This jacket epitomises the best of ivy league style and tailoring. The herringbone jacket is in an excellent medium weight cloth that makes it suitable for all seasons. The sizing is perfect and the cut of the jacket meas it hangs perfectly. Well done Kamakura on another masterpiece.

Height: 6'1"
Weight: 189
Size: EU 54R / US 43R
Outstanding! Super high-quality. Better fit/finish than US made custom shirts!

NY Classic was perfect fit, just as described in the detailed size guide. The Tokyo shirt of same size was too small. But, it gave me an opportunity to experience the return/re-order process. Very smooth for US buyer. DHL pickup same day. I ordered (2) custom shirts to test the waters for make-to-ordr. Most of my shirts are custom from US brand. The off-the-rack Kamakura was superior to those. Happy new customer.

Height: 183
Weight: 80kg
Size: XL
Amazing shetalnd sweater

The perfect sweater

Height: 6'0"
Weight: 185
Excellent Fit, Look & Construction

A really nice shirt, constructed well with nice details. The print is crisp, fabric irons nicely. A standout part of my wardrobe.

Love these pants

Finally a pair of higher waisted pants that aren't shaped like a balloon. They've got a flattering masculine shapes, nice thick fabric, and still comfortable.

As the other reviewer said, check the size guide and measure yourself honestly.

Quality okay but wrapping disappointed

Tie Quality is okay. But the package comes with no wrapping or protection, doesn't feel like buying products from a brand shop that cost this price. Instead, feel like getting from a grocery store discount section. A bit disappointed.

Quality shirt but sleeves are too long

The shirt is great quality. The exception is the sleeve length which are just a tad too long for the corresponding chest and neck size when comparing to brooks brothers or j crew. A smaller shirt size with smaller sleeves would fit too slim. Take that into consideration before buying since the fit is a bit unusual in the sleeves.

Shipping was a nightmare and it's not true to size at all. The chest is too tight and the waist too loose.. but I checked carefully against garment sizes comparing to the RL shirts I own so I am very surprised. I won't buy this brand again.

Top notch quality…

Normally, I’d spend some time with the product before reviewing its attributes, but I felt it safe to comment on some of the finer points. First, the shirt right out of packaging, went onto the ironing board. This shirt is a dream to iron, and takes very little effort to remove creases. Understanding that this is a washable wool; in other words, the wool has been ‘superwashed’; there are positives and negatives to consider in this processing, but in this case, it has allowed for a material to produce a sheen, unlike that of untreated wool. The shirt, drapes, beautifully, and the Tokyo fit is a nearly a tailored finish for my frame. I think these shirts will be all-around ideal for all seasons except for the summer, and for travel; with changing temperature conditions, will be optimal.

Beautiful Shirt

Normally, I’d spend some time with the product before reviewing its attributes, but I felt it safe to comment on some of the finer points. First, the shirt right out of packaging, went onto the ironing board. This shirt is a dream to iron, and takes very little effort to remove creases. Understanding that this is a washable wool; in other words, the wool has been ‘superwashed’; there are positives and negatives to consider in this processing, but in this case, it has allowed for a material to produce a sheen, unlike that of untreated wool. The shirt, drapes, beautifully, and the Tokyo fit is a nearly a tailored finish for my frame. I think these shirts will be all-around ideal for all seasons except for the summer, and for travel; with changing temperature conditions, will be optimal.

H
Vintage Ivy Custom Sleeve Event
Hasif

Perfect shirt

Essential benefit

The sleeve shortening option is essential. How else can one get a neck and sleeve fit correct? So thank you. Is this service available for all of your Vintage Ivy OCBD's?

Hi Paul, we're glad to hear the sleeve alteration service has been helpful! Yes, this service is available for most of shirts. When placing your order, simply add the sleeve alteration service to your cart and indicate the desired sleeve length in the “Notes” section at checkout. Thanks for your support!

Height: five feet six inches
Weight: 55kg
Size: Small
A wonderful addition to my Ivy League wardrobe

This jacket embodies everything that epitomises Ivy League styling, the cut the choice of colour and the quality of workmanship are all exceptional, and so too is the fit. I am so pleased that I discovered Kamakura!

Height: 182cm
Weight: 66kg
Size: S
Most pleased

The product received is spot on to the description. The material and the color are excellent. On sizing a small is a snug fit for me. If you want a more relaxed fit or plan to wear an undershirt get a medium.

H
M253S2565QB Basic Oxford
Hyu

Excellent service and seamless delivery

Height: 6' 1"
Weight: 190lbs
Size: L
Great shirt

Great shirt, breathable fabric, and a fantastic collar